Cerebral Palsy Medical Malpractice Claims in Florida

Gregg Hollander | November 4, 2026 | Medical Malpractice

A cerebral palsy diagnosis can leave parents with difficult questions about their child’s future, including whether something went wrong during pregnancy or delivery. While many cases have no preventable cause, some families may have grounds to pursue cerebral palsy medical malpractice claims when medical errors result in permanent brain damage.

For more than 30 years, Gregg Hollander has represented individuals and families affected by significant medical negligence. At Hollander Law Firm, investigating a suspected birth injury involves examining prenatal care, fetal monitoring records, delivery decisions, and the newborn’s condition to reconstruct how the injury developed. The investigation must also account for other medical explanations and determine whether appropriate treatment would likely have changed the child’s outcome. That analysis provides the foundation for assessing whether a family has a viable claim under Florida law.

Contact us online or call (561) 347-7770 today for a free case evaluation.

What Is Cerebral Palsy?

Cerebral palsy is a group of neurological disorders that affect movement, muscle control, posture, and balance. It develops when the brain forms abnormally or sustains damage during development.

Depending on the extent and location of the brain damage, children may experience the following symptoms:

  • Muscle stiffness,
  • Involuntary movements,
  • Difficulty walking,
  • Poor coordination,
  • Intellectual disabilities,
  • Seizures,
  • Swallowing difficulties, or
  • Communication problems.

The severity of these symptoms varies considerably. Some children have mild physical limitations, while others require ongoing medical treatment, rehabilitation, and assistance with daily activities throughout their lives.

How Can Cerebral Palsy Be Medical Negligence?

Under Florida’s medical negligence law, providers must exercise the level of care expected of reasonably careful professionals with similar training. Cerebral palsy may result from medical negligence when healthcare providers fail to meet that accepted standard of care, causing preventable brain damage.

Negligent care can occur during pregnancy, childbirth, or shortly after delivery.

Examples include:

  • Missed complications during pregnancy. An obstetrician may overlook maternal infections, placental abnormalities, or signs of impaired fetal growth. Delayed diagnosis or treatment can allow complications to threaten the baby’s developing brain.
  • Failure to respond to fetal distress. Abnormal fetal heart rate patterns may indicate that the baby is not receiving enough oxygen. Failing to recognize concerning patterns or perform a medically necessary emergency Cesarean delivery can prolong oxygen deprivation.
  • Improper management of birth emergencies. Placental abruption, uterine rupture, and umbilical cord prolapse can abruptly interrupt the baby’s oxygen supply. Delayed intervention may result in permanent neurological injury.
  • Delayed treatment after birth. Some newborns develop hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), a brain injury caused by insufficient oxygen and blood flow. Failing to recognize HIE or to initiate appropriate treatment for eligible newborns may worsen outcomes.

These circumstances do not automatically establish malpractice. Medical evidence must show that a provider’s negligence more likely than not caused or worsened the child’s brain injury.

What Evidence Can Be Used to Prove Cerebral Palsy Negligence?

Proving cerebral palsy medical negligence requires medical evidence establishing what caused the child’s brain injury, when it occurred, and whether proper medical treatment probably would have prevented or reduced the harm.

A delivery summary alone rarely provides enough information.

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Prenatal medical records. Laboratory results, ultrasound findings, maternal diagnoses, and clinical notes may reveal complications requiring additional monitoring or intervention.
  • Fetal monitoring records. Original electronic heart rate tracings can establish when concerning patterns appeared and how the medical team responded. Their timestamps must be compared with nursing notes and physician communications.
  • Labor and delivery records. These document medication administration, medical decisions, emergency interventions, and the timing of a Cesarean delivery.
  • Newborn medical records. Umbilical cord blood gases, Apgar scores, resuscitation records, neurological examinations, and NICU documentation help assess the baby’s condition immediately after birth.
  • Brain imaging and developmental evaluations. MRI findings, neurological assessments, and relevant genetic testing can help distinguish an injury related to oxygen deprivation from other possible causes.

Hollander Law Firm examines these records to identify specific failures in care and determine whether they contributed to the child’s brain injury. Under Florida law, a malpractice claim generally requires a verified written medical expert opinion supporting the allegations of negligence and resulting injury before formal notice of intent to sue is served.

What Is NICA and How Does It Affect Cerebral Palsy Lawsuits?

The Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association (NICA) administers a state program for certain severe neurological injuries occurring during childbirth. Unlike an ordinary malpractice lawsuit, NICA does not require families to prove that a healthcare provider acted negligently.

A qualifying birth-related neurological injury must meet the following requirements:

  • Involve a brain or spinal cord injury. The injury must result from oxygen deprivation or mechanical injury during labor, delivery, or immediate postdelivery resuscitation in a hospital.
  • Cause substantial permanent impairment. The child must have substantial and permanent physical and mental impairment.
  • Meet birthweight requirements. The child must weigh at least 2,500 grams in a single birth or 2,000 grams in a multiple birth under the 2026 statutory definition.
  • Involve a qualifying provider. Obstetrical services must have been provided by a participating physician or another qualifying provider under the statute.

The statutory definition excludes disability caused by genetic or congenital abnormalities.

When an injury falls within NICA’s coverage, the program replaces malpractice lawsuits. If the injury is found compensable under NICA, a family generally cannot pursue an ordinary malpractice lawsuit for the same injury against covered providers, subject to narrow statutory exceptions.

The distinction matters because NICA provides defined benefits, while a negligence lawsuit may allow recovery for a broader range of damages.

FAQs

Do I Need a Medical Malpractice Lawyer If My Child Was Diagnosed with Cerebral Palsy?

A medical malpractice lawyer can investigate whether negligent care caused your child’s brain injury and determine whether you have grounds to pursue compensation. This involves working with qualified medical experts to evaluate the evidence and address alternative explanations for the injury.

Legal representation can also help with:

  • Filing deadlines. Florida medical malpractice lawsuits and NICA claims have different deadlines and procedural requirements. An attorney can identify the applicable rules and prevent mistakes that could jeopardize your claim.
  • Investigation. An attorney can obtain prenatal, labor and delivery, and newborn medical records to reconstruct the events surrounding your child’s injury. Working with qualified medical experts, the attorney can identify missed warning signs, treatment delays, and other evidence of negligence.
  • Settlement negotiations. Hospitals and insurers may argue that the injury was unavoidable or occurred before delivery. A lawyer can challenge unsupported claims, evaluate settlement offers, and negotiate compensation that accounts for your child’s long-term needs.
  • Peace of mind. An attorney can manage medical record requests, expert reviews, and communications with insurers. This allows you to focus on your child’s treatment and daily care rather than managing a complicated legal process.

Having legal counsel also means receiving an informed assessment of your options before deciding whether to pursue a claim.

How Much Compensation Can I Recover If I Bring a Cerebral Palsy Negligence Claim?

Cerebral palsy compensation depends on whether the claim falls under NICA or proceeds as a traditional Florida medical malpractice lawsuit.

Under NICA, qualifying families may receive payment for medical care, rehabilitation, specialized equipment, certain family-provided care, transportation, and housing assistance. The family award’s maximum began at $250,000 in 2021 and increases by 3% each January, making the 2026 maximum approximately $289,819. Covered care expenses are evaluated separately, and program rules govern reimbursement.

In a medical malpractice lawsuit, recoverable damages may include:

  • Past and future medical treatment, rehabilitation, and therapy;
  • Wheelchairs, communication devices, and necessary home modifications;
  • Long-term nursing assistance and other support services;
  • Lost future earning capacity; and
  • Pain, suffering, physical impairment, and diminished enjoyment of life.

A child’s care needs can change significantly over time, particularly as they enter adulthood and their parents can no longer provide the same level of assistance. Medical and financial experts can help estimate these future expenses so that any settlement accounts for the child’s long-term needs, rather than just the costs already incurred.

Can I File a Claim If My Child Was Diagnosed with Cerebral Palsy Years After Birth?

A later diagnosis does not necessarily prevent a claim, but Florida imposes strict filing deadlines. If you do not file by the deadline, you generally lose your right to recover.

For an ordinary medical malpractice lawsuit, the deadline is generally two years from the negligent incident or its discovery, or when it reasonably should have been discovered. Absent certain exceptions, you generally cannot bring a claim after the deadline.

NICA has a separate five-year filing deadline measured from the child’s birth. Waiting for a definitive cerebral palsy diagnosis can therefore create a risk of losing eligibility.

An attorney can evaluate both deadlines based on your child’s birth date, medical history, and the timing of the suspected negligence.

When cerebral palsy results in permanent neurological impairment, the consequences can extend across your child’s entire life. Establishing whether preventable medical negligence caused that injury requires a thorough evaluation of both the clinical evidence and Florida law.

At Hollander Law Firm, we approach cerebral palsy medical malpractice claims by examining what healthcare providers knew, how they responded, and whether different medical care probably would have prevented the injury.

Contact us online or call (561) 347-7770 for a free consultation to discuss the circumstances surrounding your child’s birth, the medical evidence, and your family’s legal options.

Legal References Used to Inform This Page

To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:​